Home » Multi-Factor Authentication » Authenticator Apps » Google Authenticator vs. SMS Authentication: Which is More Secure?

Google Authenticator vs. SMS Authentication: Which is More Secure?


Table of Contents

Regarding online security, two-factor authentication (2FA) is a critical aspect to consider.

It adds an extra layer of protection to ensure that only authorized users can access an account, even if their password is compromised.

With so many 2FA options available, it can be difficult to decide which method is best for you. In this post, we’ll look closely at two popular options: Google Authenticator and SMS authentication, and compare their security features.

Google Authenticator

Google Authenticator is a free, open-source app that generates one-time passcodes for 2FA. It works with many online services, including Google, Microsoft, Dropbox, and more.

You’ll need to download the app to your smartphone or tablet to set up Google Authenticator. Once the app is installed, you’ll need to scan a QR code or manually enter a secret key to link it to your account.

Some of the key security features of Google Authenticator include:

  • One-time passcodes: Each time you log in to a service, Google Authenticator generates a new, unique passcode that can be used only once. This means that even if a hacker intercepts your passcode, they won’t be able to use it to access your account.
  • Offline access: Google Authenticator works offline, so you can still generate passcodes even if you don’t have an internet connection. This is especially useful for travelers or those in remote areas where internet access may be limited.
  • Open-source: Being open-source makes it transparent and easy for any developer to review the code and check for any vulnerabilities.
Option to scan the QR code or enter the Secret Key in the Google Authenticator app.
Add a new account in the Google Authenticator app by scanning the QR code or manually typing the secret key.

SMS Authentication

SMS authentication is a 2FA method that uses text messages to deliver one-time passcodes to your phone. To set up SMS authentication, you’ll need to provide your phone number to the service you’re using.

The service will send a passcode to your phone via text message when you log in. You’ll then need to enter the passcode to complete the login process.

Some of the key features of SMS authentication include:

  • Convenience: SMS authentication is easy to set up and use and doesn’t require a separate app.
  • Widely available: SMS authentication is supported by many online services, so it’s a widely available 2FA option.
  • Vulnerabilities: Hackers can intercept SMS messages, and phone numbers can be ported to another carrier, allowing a hacker to receive your SMS 2FA codes. This is a significant security risk.

When it comes to security, Google Authenticator is generally considered to be the more secure option. One-time passcodes and offline access make it more difficult for hackers to access your account.

However, SMS authentication is still a solid choice if you’re looking for a convenient 2FA option that’s widely available.

In terms of convenience, SMS authentication is a clear winner. You don’t need to install any additional apps or worry about losing your phone.

However, the ease of SMS authentication comes with certain vulnerabilities. SMS messages can be intercepted by hackers and phone numbers can be transferred to another carrier, thereby enabling the hacker to receive the 2FA codes sent via SMS.

Which one is a better option?

Both Google Authenticator and SMS authentication offer solid 2FA options, but they have their own unique strengths and weaknesses.

Google Authenticator is more secure, but SMS authentication is more convenient.

The best choice depends on your priorities and the specific needs of your online accounts. It’s recommended to use a combination of both, Google Authenticator for more important accounts and SMS authentication for less important ones or where this is the only available option.

Additionally, it’s important to remember that 2FA is just one aspect of online security. It should be combined with other security measures such as strong passwords, regular updates, and monitoring of your account activity.

Some of the best practices for maintaining online security include:

  • Creating strong and unique passwords for each account.
  • Regularly updating your passwords and software.
  • Monitoring your account activity for any suspicious activity.
  • Being aware of phishing scams and avoiding clicking on suspicious links or providing personal information to untrusted sources.
  • Using a password manager to keep track of your login credentials.
  • Enabling two-factor authentication on all your accounts.
  • Keeping your device and software updated with the latest security patches.

In summary, Two-factor authentication is a crucial aspect of online security and can help protect your accounts from unauthorized access.

Google Authenticator and SMS authentication are both popular options for 2FA, but they have their own unique strengths and weaknesses.

Google Authenticator is more secure, but SMS authentication is more convenient. The best choice depends on your priorities and the specific needs of your online accounts.

Additionally, it’s essential to combine 2FA with other security measures such as strong passwords, regular updates, and regular account monitoring to ensure maximum security.

My Favorite Software and Hardware.

Thank you for reading this article. I hope you found it helpful. Here is the list of the software and hardware I am personally using, which I believe you may also find useful. These are affiliate links, so if you decide to use any of them, I will earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. But in all honesty, this is the exact software I have installed on my computer and the hardware I have been using to secure my online accounts or store my passwords.

1Password Password Manager - I have been using 1Password for over three years now, and in my opinion, it is the best Password Manager yet. You can try 1Password for free or check the latest deals on the 1Password website.

YubiKey - This is a hardware authentication device that you can use to protect your online accounts or even computers. If you are thinking of getting one, I will highly recommend Yubikey 5C NFC, which, thanks to the NFC, can also be used with your phone. If you are an Apple user, the YubiKey 5Ci is the best next choice, in my opinion.

Bitdefender Total Security - I had tried other Anti-Virus software whenever my Bitdefender license was about to expire. However, at the end of the day, this is still my favorite Anti-Virus. You can check the latest offers on the Bitdefender site.